My baby... ~MAXIMUS~

Monday, September 20, 2010

Strategy Reflection Ch. 2

Michelle Southard

Strategy Reflection
Ch. 2
Strategy: Identifying Similarities and Differences

Part 1: Summary

In the book Classroom Instruction, chapter 2 has information on identifying similarities and differences. The chapter goes into get detail about some of the ways research have shown that these mental operations (identifying similarities and differences) are basic human thought. When a teacher is encouraging their students to use this theory they should 1. present student with explicit guidance in identify similarities and differences 2. ask student to independently identify similarities and differences 3. representing similarities and differences in graphic or symbolic form and 4. identification of similarities and differences can be accomplished in a variety of ways. The chapter also encourages teachers to compare, classify, create metaphors, and create analogies. The chapter shows examples of two graphic organizers for comparison: the Venn diagram and the comparison matrix. The Venn diagram allows students easily see the similarities and differences for each characteristic used in the comparison. The comparison Matrix provides a more detailed approach to comparison. Teacher-Directed metaphors provides a scaffold on which the student can build and student-directed metaphors are more student-directed when they are presented with a challenge.

Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class.

In chapter 3 of the Art and Science of Teaching and in chapter 2 of the Classroom Instruction I was able to draw a comparison between the two readings. Both provides information on student-generated tasks/student-directed metaphors. In chapter 3 of the Art and Science of Teaching is provides the reader with information on how powerful it is to have students generate their own tasks. The teacher should give specific directions and still administer each student. In chapter 2 of the Classroom Instruction it shows examples of student-directed analogies which is asking students to provide more information than a teacher would typically do. These tasks require more explanation from the student and that students take the responsibility for providing evidence for their self and helping them to gain more responsibility. In my opinion these concepts are the same objective to allow student to learn some material and find research by their self.

Part 3: Application or reading to my own teaching interests.

I can relate to using similarities and differences in the classrooms and also using graphic organizers to succeed and better understand the material. I can remember in one of my social studies classes we were talking about the women in the “roaring 20's” and we compared them to the women today, in the way they dress, wear their hair, etc...The teacher drew the Venn diagram on the board and while we were looking at pictures in our book we were to point out their similarities and differences. This really helped the students to be able to understand and see these differences clearly. The teacher allowed the students to get involved in the classroom and it also helps to shows the teacher that the students mind are thinking correctly and working on understanding a particular concept.

1 comment:

  1. I can remember back to my classes when we used the Venn diagram to compair 2 dates in history. This is a good way to show the class the differences and what were the same. I plan to use the Venn diagram in my class one day too. You have a good point that it will get the students involved in the class as well.

    ReplyDelete